Which is better for you, an HR54 Genie or HS17 Genie 2?

When it comes to DIRECTV upgrades, you have a choice. You can choose the sleek DIRECTV HR54 Genie or the monolithic HS17 Genie 2. These two options are both great, but you’ll have to decide which one to get when you upgrade. Unfortunately you can’t have both.

HR54 Genie

The HR54 Genie is pretty much what you would expect out of a DVR if you’ve been using one for a while. It’s got the typical DVR shape, although it’s smaller and sleeker than most older DVRs.

DVR functions

The HR54 can record five shows at once and store up to 200 hours of HD programs on its 1TB drive. It can record 4K programs but it can’t display them — you’ll need a separate box for that.

TV outputs

With an HR54 Genie, you can get video straight from the DVR. You can also put mini clients (both the HD and 4K kind) in up to three rooms. This means four-room support. You can use wireless clients if you add a separate video bridge. Each client box acts like a DVR. You can pause live TV, set and watch recordings, and use interactive features.

Overall experience

Compared to the HS17 Genie 2, the HR54 itself is going to seem a little faster as you go through the menus. However, the client boxes will seem a little slower. It won’t be enough to stop you from enjoying TV, but you’ll notice the difference.

Upgradeability

The HR54 can be part of a whole system that can include other non-Genie DVRs and receivers that can all share recorded programs. However, with the other receivers and DVRs in the mix you can either have a small quiet box or you can pause live TV. You can’t have both. You can’t have multiple HR54s but you can have other lesser DVRs as well as the HR54.

HS17 Genie 2

The Genie 2 is the latest box from AT&T. It’s designed as a server-only, meaning it sits in some unused location in your house and doesn’t connect to a TV. The Genie 2 is designed to take the place of a bunch of other little boxes in your setup, so it can power the dish, connect to your home internet and connect to wireless clients all without any other boxes in place. It’s supposed to be an all-in-one solution that works with 99.5% of the residential installations out there.

DVR Functions

The HS17 Genie 2 can record up to 7 programs at once and store up to 400 hours of HD on its 2TB hard drive. It records SD, HD, and 4K. However, as a server it doesn’t output video at all.

TV outputs

In order to output to a TV you’ll need client boxes. You can have up to two 4K clients PLUS five HD clients for a seven-room system. The HD clients can be wired or wireless (there isn’t a 4K wireless client) and you don’t need a separate box to go wireless.

Overall Experience

You’ll get very adequate performance out of the client boxes. They’ll seem faster than they do on the HR54. There’s no direct output from the HS17 like there is on the HR54. You’ll need to find a place to put this big tower that isn’t really obtrusive. It’s not designed to fit in a typical entertainment center.

Upgradeability

Simply put, there isn’t any. Once you connect 7 clients to it, you’re done. You can’t add any more DIRECTV equipment if you have a Genie 2. That’s going to be ok for most people but it can be limiting for power users.

The bottom line

I tend to think most people will prefer the experience of the HS17 Genie 2. Seven rooms is more than enough in nearly every case and while the box is a bit over a foot tall, you can hide it in a room where it’s not seen or even put it in a closet if there’s enough ventilation.

On the other hand if you are the sort to want a man cave or she shed or any sort of really complex setup, seven clients may not do it for you. That’s where you should really consider the unlimited flexibility of the HR54 Genie. You could literally have 100 receivers in addition to the HR54 Genie if you wanted to. If that sounds interesting to you, definitely choose HR54. Otherwise, HS17 is probably better.